If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, we may receive an affiliate commission.
You don’t want to spend all day preparing, kneading, filling, wrapping and sticking it in the oven only for the crusts to burn and the pie become ruined. If you happen to fill up the pie a little too much, you can experience spillage in your oven, which is a real pain to clean and could cause your oven to smoke a little more. By putting on a pie crust shield, this will prevent your crust from burning and will keep the filling inside the crust, so it won’t overflow. A shield will prevent your masterpiece from becoming a hard to eat blackened mess. These work on both sweet and savory pies and can even work on something like a deep dish pizza. We’ve hand selected five of the best pie crust shields on the market to help you become a better pie maker. Take a look and enjoy golden crusts each and every time.
Best for Home or Commercial Baking
Whether you’re making pies for your family or you own a bakery and are selling your delicious creations, you should consider utilizing the Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Protector Shield. This fits 9.5″ to 10″ pie plates and allows them to rise, reduce spillage, and prevent pie crusts from over browning or burning. This made from aluminum, so it’s strong and durable. This is great for blind baking empty pie crusts as well and it can be used with homemade or frozen pie crusts. The more convenient and economical choice, this is better than wadding up aluminum foil. It fits baking dishes with fluted edges and carrying handles. You can easily clean this, as it can be put in the dishwasher.
- Made from aluminum for durability
- Great for blind baking empty pie crusts and can be used with homemade or frozen crusts
- Fits baking dishes with fluted edges and carrying handles
Best Adjustable Shield
Burning doesn’t look good on your skin when you sit outside without any lotion on, so why would you want it on your pie? With the Talisman Designs 1507 Authentic Adjustable Pie Crust Shield, that won’t be an issue. You can use this with a pie that’s 8.5″ in diameter all the way up to 11″. It’s adjustable, so you can close it around your pie crust and fit it properly. You’ll get a nice glow on your crust, thanks to this silicone pie shield. It is reusable and flexible, as the one-piece design can be fit to your parameters. It is made from BPA-free and FDA food-safe silicone that can get up to 500°F. You can wash this in the dishwasher.
- Adjustable so you can close it around your pie crust
- Made from BPA-free and FDA food-safe silicone
- Reusable and flexible
For smaller families, you probably don’t need multiple pie shields. The Norpro Pie Crust Shield is an excellent option that will keep some money in your wallet. You can place it on top of your pie crust before baking and then leave it on the pie during the entire baking process. It allows the pie to rise in the middle and prevents both burning of the crust and spillage on the edges. This will fit pies up to 10″ in diameter and can be used in ovens as hot as 450°F. It is FDA-approved, so it’s safe to use in your kitchen and you can wash it in your dishwasher.
- Allow the pie to rise in the middle
- Fits pies up to 10″ in diameter
Not everybody in your family will always agree on their favorite fillings for pies, so you might as well make multiple. Protect those crusts with the Cornucopia Brands Silicone Pie Crust Shields 2 Pack. These pie crust shields will keep the crusts from getting burnt and they can be fitted to match up with your pie plates. This has a tab and notches for adjusting between 8.5″ and 11″. These can also be used for deep dish pie plates and they come in a fashionable color of green. They are safe to put in the dishwasher and are made from food-grade silicone.
- Keeps the crusts from getting burnt
- Has a tab and notches for adjusting between sizes
- Can be used for deep dish pie plates
Best for Mini Pies
Individual pies are easier to eat and so you can utilize the Webake Mini Silicone Pie Shield 4-Pack to your advantage. These measure five to six inches to best adjust around your pies. This will fit rimmed pie dishes and ones with fluted edges and carrying handles. Made from 100% food-grade silicone, these can be kept in temperatures anywhere between -40°F and 446°F. This pack comes with four, so you don’t have to just make one mini pie. They can be used with homemade or frozen pie crusts.
- Measure five to six inches to best adjust around your pies
- Fit rimmed pie dishes and ones with fluted edges and carrying handles
- Comes with four shields