Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
  1. Prime Day Fire TV Deals
    12:56 Deals

    Amazon’s early Prime Day smart TV deals are unreal, including a 70″ 4K Fire TV…

  2. Prime Day Deals
    09:43 Deals

    These early Prime Day deals have prices so low, it’s like Amazon made a mistake

  3. Best Beach Towels For Sand
    11:44 Deals

    I’m never going to the beach again without this brilliant $18 Amazon find

  4. Amazon Deals
    10:30 Deals

    Today’s top deals: Free $15 Amazon credit, $530 70″ TV, $4 smart plugs, $8 sma…

  5. Best Amazon Deals Today
    07:58 Deals

    15 hidden Amazon deals that are so exclusive, they’re only for Prime members

Legendary phone reviewer explains why the Pixel 2 and iPhone 8’s camera scores are flawed

October 13th, 2017 at 2:13 PM
Pixel 2 vs. iPhone 8 Plus DxOMark

We’ve seen a barrage of DxOMark camera reviews in the past few weeks, as several high-end smartphones came out, all of them sporting top-of-the-line camera experience. First, the camera pros declared the iPhone 8 Plus to be the best smartphone camera they ever tested. Its score was tied by the Galaxy Note 8 quick after that. Then came the Pixel 2 which took the top spot, according to DxOMark’s ranking system.

The problem with assigning scores to camera performance is that it’s not an entirely objective endeavor. While you can measure some camera characteristics with precision, there are various aspects concerning photo quality that are subjective. And a new video perfectly illustrates why DxOMark’s scoring system is significantly flawed.

Marques Brownlee explains that DxOMark scores aren’t entirely arbitrary, but they’re not adequately explained in these reviews. Moreover, the final grade a phone gets is not an average of all the photo and video scores. And that’s something we pointed out when looking at the Pixel 2 review, a phone that has a higher rating than the iPhone 8 Plus and Galaxy Note 8 but offers worse portrait and zoom features.

Brownlee also tackles one other issue we’ve identified with these scores. The Pixel 2’s record 99 score isn’t out of a maximum of 100. No, phones will surpass that mark, and some cameras are already ranked over 100 on DxOMark. But that’s not immediately apparent to readers, and you have to go through the entire review to find the fine print that explains it.

Finally, Brownlee also explains one issue we have not addressed in our coverage of these reviews, the fact that DxOMark works with certain companies on improving camera performance — like it did with OnePlus earlier this year. However, the DxOMark fails to identify in these reviews any potential conflict of interest when reviewing smartphones from companies that have a business relationship with DxOMark. Or I totally missed it.

For example, given the fact that Google bragged with the DxOMark Pixel 2 score on stage during its recent media event, I’d be inclined to think Google is a customer. And I may be wrong.

Check out Brownlee’s full video on DxOMark, which I personally score 99 out of to-be-decided, below.

Chris Smith started writing about gadgets as a hobby, and before he knew it he was sharing his views on tech stuff with readers around the world. Whenever he's not writing about gadgets he miserably fails to stay away from them, although he desperately tries. But that's not necessarily a bad thing.

Popular News