Whether you’re an amateur baker who whips up delicious cookies all the time or just someone who enjoys baking cookies once in a while for holidays, having a good cookie sheet to bake on is an absolute must. It might seem like cookie sheets are all the same, but we can assure you that’s not the case at all. We’ve tested more than a dozen popular baking sheets and you’ll find the best of the bunch right here.
Best Commercial Cookie Sheet
People who really know their way around a kitchen likely want a good aluminum cookie sheet to bake on, and it doesn’t get any better than the Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker’s Sheet. This large aluminum tray is perfectly crafted to capture heat and keep it spread evenly across the surface. There’s also a reinforced encapsulated steel rim around the edges to prevent warping even after years of use.
Best Nonstick Cookie Sheet
If you’re looking for a good nonstick cookie sheet, you’ve come to the right place. The Rachael Ray Nonstick Bakeware Cookie Pan Set comes with three deep sheets so you always have the exact size you’re looking for. They’re made from durable steel that resists warping, and they even have wide silicone grips so you can move them around without needing oven mitts.
Best Large Cookie Sheet
If you have a nice big oven and you want to use as much of that space as possible, you definitely want to get yourself a Wilton 15 x 21-Inch 2105-0109 Perfect Results Cookie Pan. This nonstick pan is almost two feet wide and over one foot deep, so you can fit tons of cookies on a single sheet. It’s even dishwasher safe.
