Apple wins permanent injunction against Psystar

General

psystar2

It is the end of the line for Psystar as U.S. District Judge William Alsup has issued a permanent injunction against the Apple clone maker. The injunction prevents Psystar from pursuing its core hardware business by banning the following:

  • Copying, selling, offering to sell, distributing, or creating derivative works of plaintiff’s copyrighted Mac OS X software without authorization from the copyright holder
  • Intentionally inducing, aiding, assisting, abetting, or encouraging any other person or entity to infringe plaintiff’s copyrighted Mac OS X software;
  • Circumventing any technological measure that effectively controls access to plaintiff’s copyrighted Mac OS X software, including, but not limited to, the technological measure used by Apple to prevent unauthorized copying of Mac OS X on non-Apple computers
  • Manufacturing, importing, offering to the public, providing, or otherwise trafficking in any technology, product, service, device, component, or part thereof that is primarily designed or produced for the purpose of circumventing a technological measure that effectively controls access to plaintiff’s copyrighted Mac OS X software, including, but not limited to, the technological measure used by Apple to prevent unauthorized copying of Mac OS X on non-Apple computer
  • Manufacturing, importing, offering to the public, providing, or otherwise trafficking in any technology, product, service, device, component, or part thereof that is primarily designed or produced for the purpose of circumventing a technological measure that effectively protects the rights held by plaintiff under the Copyright Act with respect to its copyrighted Mac OS X software.

Psystar has until December 31th, 2009 to fully comply with the ruling and must begin the process immediately using a method that provides the fastest route to compliance. Psystar may have to shutter the hardware portion of its business but the legal status of Psystar’s $50 Rebel EFI software remains unclear. In his ruling, Alsup does not cite the Rebel EFI software specifically, claiming that Psystar failed to disclose exactly what the application did. In case Psystar has high hopes of continuing to sell its Rebel EFI software, Alsup issued a  stern warning, ‘What is certain, however, is that until such a motion is brought, Psystar will be selling Rebel EFI at its peril, and risks finding itself in contempt if its new venture falls within the scope of the injunction.” Will this admonishment permanently close the doors on Psystar or will the rebel company stage one last battle?

Read

18 Comments
  • Peter B

    But…but…its Microsoft thats the big evil corporation. Apple loves you and hugs puppies at night.

    Appl€ doesn’t have the same punch as Micro$oft does it?

    • Ender

      How the hell does anybody give a negative rating to something as funny as the above comment. Shit. LMFAO!!!!

  • Scott

    I almost bought one at the begining of 2009. I think it was a great chance Psystar took. It showed that Apple really does over charge for their hardware. Their software has always been pretty inexpensive (cost of OS X compared to Windows). If they’re able to keep the EFI application to install OS X, then I might still consider one next year.

  • James

    Finally this shit is over and TBH, making a hackintosh shouldn’t be hard for anyone one in this site.

  • Ryan

    Apple blows chunks.

  • BobH

    screw Apple. Guess they can’t handle competition…

  • Eric

    Pystar should switch to cloning the XBOX 360 instead so we can all go back to hating Microsoft when they lay down the exact same legal smack down….

  • RA

    Unable to download EFI free trail now.

  • http://www.facebook.com/Drummer85 Ndamukong Suh

    IM IN UR KOMPEWTURS EATIN UR GRAFIX KARDZ

  • Jarrett

    If you are a holder of any significant IP, then you know you wouldn’t want anyone using it without your OK. You just can’t do something because you want to.
    I know some of you on this site pirate stuff, one of my old boss’ use to as well. I told her to allow me to sell one large product in the morning and then just give it away to the rest of the customers for the day. After a failed attempt of arguing she got my point. She still steals media, now though she knows she is stealing.
    In a free market you get to determine how much your product is worth. If the customer doesn’t agree then you will lower prices or go out of business. Apple doesn’t lower prices because people like to buy good products. You might disagree with that and that’s fine. It is hard for a shareholder to disagree with a formula that has made many people wealthy . I mean hell give Apple the due credit they deserve they have over $30 billion in cash on hand.
    I know, I know, we as Americans love to hate, but we all know truth when we see it.

  • bag of crackberry

    Hmm my 2ghz core i7 laptop with a gtx 280m graphics card and 6gigs of ram and 2 500gig 7200rpm hard drives !!!!!, cough cough my laptop is more powerufull than even the most expensive macbook pro lol….. graphics design, video encoding, audio encoding, video editing are lightning fast on here.. FTW my dorm mate has a 15inch macbook pro with the dual gpu’s and the 3ghz core 2 duo and he is thinking about selling it and getting the same laptop i got lol COPTER AHHHHHH

    • loki

      ^^^ Post the specs of your computer.

      It is easy to say that my hardware is better. All I can say is “That’s what she said”

      Until then, provide some specs.

  • loki

    ^^^ oops, wrong post. Too many tabs open.

    dammit!!!!

  • http://KatieLawrence.com Katie Lawrence

    I love Apple products but I do they sometimes they are too ‘closed’

  • ash

    If pystar wants to spite apple, it should release it’s REBEL EFI to the public domain. Sure that will make it easier for apple to work around, but it will help bring down apple’s restriction on what hardware people can use.

  • ucfgrad93

    Hopefully this is the end of Psystar.

  • Draven

    But yet it’s PERFECTLY fine for Apple to run Bootcamp and take full advantage of Windows on a platform it was not designed for, right???

    Hypocrisy at its best. But then again, Apple’s entire set of business practices include corporate shystering, misdirection, half-truths, outright B.S., and taking advantage of a techno-illiterate consumer base that really doesn’t know anything about computers to begin with.

    So….yeah, I’m not siding with Apple on this one. They just spelled HYPOCRITE across their greasy foreheads.

  • Brad

    Apple had a golden opportunity here, an opportunity to finally develop a licensing plan for third-party manufacturers, in order to vastly increase its marketshare. Instead, they decided to stick with the “you don’t tell us what you want, we tell you what you want” mentality. Until that ends, I have no plans to buy any Apple products, due to both principal and price.

    The OS has good points, but for what I use a computer for, it’s not even remotely the best OS choice, and I don’t think their hardware is anything special. Most models are underpowered, and they clearly are focusing on making it pretty, rather than functional, and I don’t think it’s all that pretty. I could care less if a laptop casing is milled out of a single block of aluminum, just give me a freakin’ right-hand mouse button. A mouse button as big as a spacebar will never fly with me.

    From a legal perspective, I admit Psystar really didn’t have much of a leg to stand on. Apple remains the owner of Mac OS, and by the TOS agreement, you only purchase the right to use the software, and that right can be revoked if you use it in a way other than what’s dictated by the TOS. Psystar violated the TOS agreement. I wanted to see them exceed to teach Apple a lesson, but ultimately, they were in the wrong. I just wish Apple had learned a lesson in all this, but apparently they haven’t. I imagine as long as Steve Jobs remains in charge, not much will change. You know, there are too many Steves around here, Jobs, Ballmer, etc. I think we need to ban anymore Steves from becoming tech company CEOs, because they’re all goofy. XD

blog comments powered by Disqus