Why you type two words into reCAPTCHA.

General

reCAPTCHA

If you’ve signed up for any sort of online service there is a high likelihood you’re very familiar with CAPTCHA. CAPTCHAs are “used by many websites to prevent abuse from ‘bots,’ or automated programs usually written to generate spam.” They essentially try to verify whether a user filling out a text form is human or a bot. Have you ever wondered why you are sometimes prompted with two CAPTCHA words instead of one? Google explains:

reCAPTCHA improves the process of digitizing books by sending words that cannot be read by computers to the Web in the form of CAPTCHAs for humans to decipher. More specifically, each word that cannot be read correctly by OCR is placed on an image and used as a CAPTCHA. This is possible because most OCR programs alert you when a word cannot be read correctly.

But if a computer can’t read such a CAPTCHA, how does the system know the correct answer to the puzzle? Here’s how: Each new word that cannot be read correctly by OCR is given to a user in conjunction with another word for which the answer is already known. The user is then asked to read both words. If they solve the one for which the answer is known, the system assumes their answer is correct for the new one. The system then gives the new image to a number of other people to determine, with higher confidence, whether the original answer was correct.

Currently, we are helping to digitize old editions of the New York Times and books from Google Books.

CAPTCHAs can be frustrating at times, but take solace in knowing that once entered correctly, you’ve just completed a tiny bit of community service.

[Via Reddit]

Read

29 Comments
  • Anonymous Coward

    BGR == fail. The way Google’s reCAPTCHA works has been known about for months.

    • Andrew Munchbach

      I know. I just thought it was cool so I wrote it up.

      • Joey

        I liked it. Haters gonna hate.

      • http://music.kwaping.com Kwaping

        Yeah I liked the article too, thanks Andrew.

    • http://TedAvery.ca Ted Avery

      Yeah, all you had to do was go to the reCAPTCHA website to see this. Plus they have always said “Stop spam, read books”

  • Allen Walker

    Whatever, I didn’t know it.. (Not that I was going out of my way to find out or anything) but it’s still interesting.

    I just know these buggers are super annoying..

    • bill

      well you are an idiot and know nothing about technology

  • http://quarterlifemag.com Paul Eulette

    “The user is then asked to read both words. If they solve the one for which the answer is known, the system assumes their answer is correct for the new one.”

    ===

    I’ve noticed on Facebook, you can kinda half-ass both words of your typed answers, and it goes through. Not really the most secure, but I don’t mind.

    • DigDug

      You only need to type one word of the recaptcha to get access. I can choose the “correct” word to type about 95% of the time. I am still baffled why people insist on typing both words when only 1 is needed.

  • http://www.tuttogiochigratis.com Giochi

    Let me say that there is nothing more frustrating than recaptcha

  • Jamaal

    This would make a lot more sense if I knew what OCR was..?

  • Kyle

    Must be a boring day around BGR offices

    Isn’t there another android/apple/Evo 4g/motorola droid x/verizon iphone/samsung galaxy s phones/steve jobs/at&t/droid/steve jobs again/droid/at&t/verizon/verizon iphone news story somewhere out there?

  • William

    I demand to get paid for my work now!

    • Jay

      I was waiting to see who would be the first to say this ;)

  • http://www.rossmanngroup.com Louis Rossmann

    I despise captchas.

    A lot of them on some site’s search functions are unreadable.

  • molerx

    Just tell me who do I sue for not paying my work??

    • Brian

      You must have gotten lost, this isn’t Consumerist.

  • iamjoel5

    …And now you know

    • Andrew Munchbach

      …and knowing is half the battle.

      • Sgt Slaughter

        Cobra Commander’s going DOOOOWN!

  • DigDug

    I’ve known for several years that you only need to type in one of the two words to get through. This is common knowledge, or at least, should be. It is almost always the longer word that is easier to read that works (vs. the shorter word that is harder to read).

  • Nik

    Text-based Authentication is a thing of the past and still continues to be a problem for most people along with it still allowing for SPAM/BOTS to get through you have to now contend with Phish Attacks. Anyone that has ever used CAPTCHA and/or RECAPTCHA know that is becomes a complete hassle trying to decipher the random words along with have to start over if you input the incorrect verbiage.

    Now imagine if you have bad vision and need to go online for something, it is a complete nightmare and make the online experience not very enjoyable for anyone.

    At first you had some kind of text-based authentication which was single word and those usually are random letters, numbers and symbols but those can be easier broken, so along came RECAPTCHA which use any two random word to authenticate. These words cannot be read half the time and sometimes the wording combination is down right offensive..

    You want to feel secure and minus the HEADACHES..Check out this company located in California..www.confidenttechnologies.com

    They got this one figured out and it is FREE!!!!

    • http://quarterlifemag.com Paul Eulette

      LOL — are you kidding me, I live for the inappropriate/random ones! When else do you get the chance to type “nuns backwash” and it be ok?

      I’m just saying.

  • jack

    has any one ever pushed the “audio” link… the whole thing is broken and gives out random sound clips… some movies, some tv shows, some crazy stuff i’ve never heard before

  • Jojo100

    After reading this article and the comments I tried it on Ticketmaster.com – no go. If you don’t type both words correctly you’ll be denied access.
    Please check it out, guys.

  • SquareWheel

    Pretty well known, I think.

  • http://nowsci.com Ben Curtis

    You should combine this writeup of an analysis of 4chan’s hack on it during the Times.com survey of most influential people.

blog comments powered by Disqus