I’ve owned a Nintendo 3DS ever since the day it launched. It’s not the most inventive or the most attractive portable on the market, but it features an incredible selection of first-party and third-party content. But its physical limitations have always bothered me, to the point where I simply started taking my PS Vita on trips with me rather than my 3DS.

The New 3DS XL is going to change that.

LAST TIME: Nintendo 3DS review: seeing double

In case you haven’t heard, Nintendo is releasing yet another renovation of the 3DS in the United States. The New 3DS XL, despite its awkward name, is the best version of the console Nintendo has ever made.

If the title of this article didn’t give it away, I am not comparing the New 3DS XL to each and every one of its predecessors, but rather the original 3DS (the only one I’ve ever owned).

First off, size matters. The New 3DS is a beast, but still far more comfortable to handle than the original. It’s probably not going to fit in your old 3DS case or even your pocket, but that’s just how portable consoles have evolved. You probably wouldn’t put the Vita in your pocket either, unless you want a scratched screen and a twisted analog stick.

As for the upgrades, some are more baffling than others, but overall the positives outweigh the negatives. But let’s get the negatives out of the way first.

  1. The New 3DS doesn’t come with a charger. If you buy a New 3DS and don’t already have a 3DS charger, you’re going to have to buy one separately.
  2. You need a screwdriver to replace the SD card. You have to physically remove the bottom panel of the New 3DS to get at the external storage.
  3. You can’t use your old SD card. I had to go buy a microSD card and a standard SD card converter in order to transfer my data from one 3DS to the other.
  4. The wireless switch has vanished. If you want to preserve battery and turn off the WiFi connection, you’ll have to do so through the console’s settings menu.

Each and every one of these changes is frustrating and inscrutable, but none of them are deal breakers. Just know that if you’re upgrading from an old 3DS, you’re going to need to set aside some time, tools and a little bit of cash in order to get through the entire process.

So now that you’re thoroughly convinced that upgrading to a New 3DS isn’t worth it, it’s time to give you whiplash with all the reasons you should probably get one anyway.

  1. 3D is finally usable. You still might not have any interest in using it, but now that you don’t have to lock your skull in place in order to maintain the illusion, it’s totally feasible to play your favorite games in 3D.
  2. The C-stick is surprisingly useful. After playing through the entirety of Majora’s Mask 3D over the weekend, I can assure you that it’s a valuable addition. It just takes some getting used to.
  3. Everything moves faster. With a huge bump in processing power, the New 3DS flies in comparison to older models. Besides comfort, this was my other major complaint about the original 3DS, but it’s been solved in the New 3DS.
  4. Amiibo support. Ok, depending on how capable you are of controlling your impulses to buy collectible figurines, this might be in the wrong column, but it’s a great addition for future compatibility between the Wii U and 3DS.

The screen real estate has also expanded significantly (unless you already own a 3DS XL, then it’s about the same), giving the tiny worlds within these portable games a chance to breath. It’s also looks better — rounder edges, smarter button placement, better lights — it actually looks like a modern device.

For the first time in years, I can’t wait to play games on my 3DS. Hardware revisions are always exciting for gamers, but the sheen typically wears off within the first few days. After messing with the New 3DS for nearly a week, I can say with some confidence that I think the new model has some staying power.

Plus, there’s a whole lineup of games coming later this year that will require the power of the updated portable. If Xenoblade Chronicles 3D is on your watchlist (which it definitely should be), you’re going to have to upgrade to be able to play it. I won’t tell you whether or not you should, but after the laborious process of getting the darn thing set up, I’m having a blast rediscovering all of my favorite games on the New 3DS.

The New Nintendo 3DS XL will be available in the United States on February 13th, 2015.

Jacob started covering video games and technology in college as a hobby, but it quickly became clear to him that this was what he wanted to do for a living. He currently resides in New York writing for BGR. His previously published work can be found on TechHive, VentureBeat and Game Rant.