Nokia to pass on Android, focus on MeeGo and Symbian

General

nokia-logo

Anssi Vanjoki, the head of Nokia’s new Mobile Solutions unit, sat down with the Wall Street Journal on Thursday to discuss the future of Nokia’s struggling mobile phone business. In the brief but pointed interview, Vanjoki re-confirmed Nokia’s commitment to Symbian and MeeGo, a Linux-based mobile OS  jointly created Nokia and Intel. For the time being, Symbian will remain an integral part of the mobile giant’s handset lineup while MeeGo will form the base for a growing number of upcoming handheld gadgets, including its flagship N-series lineup. Nokia continues to push out handsets, with the Symbian^3-powered N8 slated for launch in Q3, while the first MeeGo devices are expected to land by the end of the year. Nokia shot down any possibility of an Android handset by claiming that it can best create value by focusing on its own hardware and software. Speaking of hardware, Vanjoki assures US consumers that Nokia has not forgotten about the US market and expects to bring additional handsets like the T-Mobile 5230 Neuron stateside. The interview sets the stage for the future of Nokia and addresses many of the weak points singled out by Ricky Cadden in his Farewell to Symbian-Guru post which announced the closing of his popular Symbian blog. Wonder if there is any correlation?

Read

62 Comments
  • ali

    I have to say I have been a Nokia fan for many years and I agree with most commentators that they have to be on crack to ignore Android. I have to add that Symbian is a very functional smartphone OS in a traditional push button mobile. Back when most Americans thought that the moto razr was the best invention since the sliced break, nokia had the N95 with its 5.0 megapixel camera, Wifi, GPS with downloadable maps, and TV out. Heck, there was an application called Joikuspot back in 2008 to turn your phone into a 3G wifi hotspot ( something that is still lacking almost all androids ). Also, sharing files between phones is a piece of cake using symbian without the need to install any additional programs.

    Having praised nokia/symbian, I have to turn to its bad points.
    For starters, Nokia, along with most manufacturers, were caught offguard by the success of Apple’s iphone. It would be more than a year before they were able to produce an ‘answer’ – the 5800 [ Android was being worked on during this time period] Nokia decided to use resistive touchscreens which are not easy to use. So nokia included a plastic pen to help but its more of pain than anything else. Navigating through the menu system is not very easy, you have to double click on almost anything you want to open. Browsing web pages is also problematic in that many of the pages sides get simply cutoff.
    But the number one reason why Nokia’s touchscreen phones are not very popular is the availablity of applications. There are simply not enough of them( maybe like 50-100 total). The Ovi store is a joke.

    So to summarize, Nokia/Symbian is a late comer to a very competitve touchscreen market.

    Nokia, unfortunately, is still arrogant in thinking that it will somehow magically attract developers for both meego and symbian. Thats not gonna happen. Most developers are very happy focusing on an exponentially growing Android. Even if its not the best OS out there, its what sells. Speeking of Meego, its an already dead project. Their number one supporter (intel) has come out publically last week in strong support of Android. In other words, they are about to abandon Meego.

    Sorry for the rant.

    • mike

      @ali – Your rant about 5800xm has very little connection to S^3 and S^4 and Qt as a SDK.

      Intel is also a chip maker first and makes no money directly out of MeeGo. It’s natural they want to sell chips to HTC/Motorola/etc. who stick with Android. It’s not strictly either-or (Android/MeeGo) for Intel and they definitely won’t abandon MeeGo.

      With Nokia’s N-series devices being based on MeeGo, MeeGo won’t die even if no-one else supports it. Watch and see, Nokia’s MeeGo handsets will outsell the competition (maybe not the eyePhone, but the Androids at least) as do all Nokia’s phones.

    • http://truvoipbuzz.com Alok @ TruVoIPBuzz

      @ali, it is not so much about the quality of MeeGo or Symbian. No doubt they are quality mobile OS and have huge potential. The question is about Nokia’s ability to engage developers and users to adopt MeeGo.

      As a developer would you be willing to develop for MeeGo, as a user would you be willing to adopt a MeeGo smartphone? Android give a ready made platform to Nokia to get some traction in the smart devices segment.

      With their current strategy, Nokia will be spreading its resources developing both OS and hardware and probably succeed with none. For Nokia’s shareholders, adopting Android is the best strategy right now.

  • What could they possibly offer?

    Ok, we’re all intelligent people here. Let’s take a look at the current market place.

    We have two major players. One offers yearly release cycle. This player manufactures one phone, provides one OS. There is one market place, and this player owns it. Picks and chooses applications it likes and has severe restrictions that openly hamper competition and dwarf innovation.

    The other player provides the framework and the OS. There are many phones, released every couple of months. The OS updated frequently and brings new features. There are many ways to obtain applications and the market encourages and promotes creativity. There are far fewer rules and restrictions. Many of the applications that exist on this platform would never be permitted in the first player’s sandbox.

    So where does this leave Nokia? A company that has consistently misjudged the market since the beginning of the century is not in a position to afford mistakes. Mistakes that occur once the product is shipped to the market are very costly…

    • thecalmcritic

      “Ok, we’re all intelligent people here. Let’s take a look at the current market place.We have two major players.”

      I’m intelligent enough to know that you’re confusing the NA market as the global one?Seriously “experts” like you need to get out of your state’s border and realize there’s a whole wide world out there?

      Look I like Android.A lot.But that doesn’t mean I’m blind to what Nokia and RIM have done over the years.It’s called “ubiquity”.Omnipresense.Existence everywhere.As market shares go that’s what the 2 underscore now maybe not with Apple’s panache or Google’s frenetic pace but it’s done right.What ubiquity means to a casual smartphone user is;a phone that works that can get the job done.E-mails.Exchange.Sync.Web browsing.Done.

      No brainer when what Nokia is doing by having a product portfolio that can cater to multiple price segments.They’re a cellphone company 1st,OS and apps 2nd.Maybe not a good arrangement in this day and age but hell it works.

      Apps are sexy sure.Looks great on marketing’s brochures and of course an app market boosts the appeal even more.But guess what?Both iOS and Android didn’t take 10 percentile off the pie just like that still.iOS has what 1mill apps now?And how much out of that are actually productive?Android proves that quantity means less,they win by openness albeit maybe fragmentation’s a problem yes but people like the idea of having the option to load or change ROMs as they please.Once awareness rise on that aspect it’ll be good.

      Nokia should be left doing what they do best and that’s bringing solid performing smartphones.And that means NOT formulating to just the NA market.

  • Nico

    I’d love to see a Nokia Android phone. Just to see what.Nokia would do.

  • rkarete

    stop all the nonsense over NOK and Android

    NOK would be suicidal to put its handset roadmap into the hands of a co that controls certification, releases schedules and features, whether they get access to Android market, etc

    NOK will try to co-opt Adnroid via QT, but anyone who says NOK shoudl go Android doesnt understadn how this industry works.

  • Anonymous

    You people aren’t thinking clearly. Nokia doesn’t need to abandon MeeGo and go full bore on Android. They can do what Samsung is doing now. Release Android phones and work on their own OS. Nokia could easily release some good mid-range to high-end devices running Andoird and use that to learn what the consumers want and tailor MeeGo to those needs. They make some good revenue in the meantime and learn what not to do.

    If the NA market is not important then why is Nokia bothering releasing devices for that market?

    • http://dreambuildshare.symbiountech.com/ VK364

      Makes perfect sense.. Nokia needs better strategists at the helm

  • mingkee

    This may not be a bad thing because I have more platform choice and I have a reason I keep using nokia.
    MeeGo is an evolution of Maemo and I am generally happy with it, so I have confidence with it.

  • Rush Limbaugh

    If Nokia got AT&T to pick up this N8-01 which everybody is claiming as the N9 or E7, and AT&T left everything alone, that would be PHENOMENAL for this market. Too bad AT&T has serious issues with anything other than the iPhone and Blackberry OS. Finally Android users know how we have felt over the years after watching AT&T ruin our phones.

    T-Mobile is showing how it should be done. Leave the software alone, leave the sales package alone, and leave the device alone (I’ll let the E73 slide on that because it still looks good)

  • Rafael

    I don’t know if anyone has made the connection yet, I didn’t bother reading all the post, lol… But sure hope this statement clarifies where Nokia stands with Symbian and now Meego. As far as I can understand by research done on my own; Symbian is still going to be Nokia’s primary smartphone OS while Meego will power their mobile computers(Eg. like MID, Netbooks and tablets). Symbian may be old, but it was made to be adaptable; thus the Symbian Foundation was formed to shape the new Symbian. Meego is new, and it is being developed for the purpose of complementing Nokia’s entry into Computers and Software(anyone remember the Booklet 3G?). And in order for these platforms to co-exist and compliment each other; QT was aquired from Trolltech. The new QT Developing Environment is the bridge that ties Symbian Smartphones to their Meego Mobile Computers.

  • http://alghienkad06.student.ipb.ac.id/ thea

    see a Nokia Android phone

  • http://dreambuildshare.symbiountech.com/ VK364

    It is a big mistake on the part of Nokia to snub Andriod. Google’s strategy was simple and humble. Their move to stop selling Nexus One phone was compatible with their strategy of selling android to all manufacturers to sell through carriers. And this worked. More android phones have been sold than iphone which is captive with ATT. Also, the tightness of applications with Andriod will offer superior user experience. Also get this.. more youth bought android phones than iphone..so, Android is already creating a solid long term base and will leverage this to drive their overall marketshare in all things web and mobile.
    If i were to make a stock recommendation, Buy Google, Hold Apple and Sell Nokia

  • Anderson Adorno Mattede

    A Nokia pirou e não vai voltar a liderança se continuar pensando assim. O Android é o futuro e quem não acreditar nisso vai morrer. O Android está para o smartphone como o Windows está para o PC.
    Nokia, pense bem, você teve uma oportunidade de virar o jogo, mas está desperdiçando.

  • http://gubatron.com/blog Gubatron

    Funny how a great company is being so stubborn and turning it’s back on what developers and customers are asking from it.

    Nokia needs to create THE Android that will blow the iPhone out of the water. Nokia is always very innovative in hardware, it’s time they admit nobody wants their software and let us do this for them.

    We’re already building for Android, please give that great phone we’re all waiting for.

    You don’t need to change your entire line, just do one great phone and see how it goes.

1 2
blog comments powered by Disqus