Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Best Butter Dish to Lock in Freshness

Best Butter Dish to Lock in Freshness

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, we may receive an affiliate commission.

Flaky biscuits or warm rolls are a staple at many holiday meals that really help keep the peace. Passing the bread products around the table bring people together and the feeling of sharing always adds to the warmth of the season. Something that is also bound to be on your table is butter, as it’s the perfect accent to your bread. We all know warm butter is easier to spread, but after you leave it out for a little while, it needs to be refrigerated. In order to keep your butter fresh, you’ll need a dish that is made for it to remain so. A butter dish allows you to seal in the freshness and is the perfect size to store on your refrigerator door or top shelf. There are a ton of options out there, so which one should you choose? We’ve highlighted great choices to make sure you’re ready for the dinner table.

Fit more than one in there

If you know you’re going to have a lot of people over for dinner or are going to be using a lot of butter for various dishes and baked goods, then you’re going to need something that holds more than just one stick. The Sweese 303.101 Large Butter Dish is perfect for you, as it can hold two sticks easily and four if you really need it to. It really seals them up for protection. This dish has an updated design that is made of a hard and very durable material. The lid is made from beech wood and has a strong, straight grain. It provides an elegant, natural style for your kitchen. Our favorite part about this dish is the removable plastic seal. You can really press the lid tightly onto the dish to make sure it locks in the freshness if you keep the plastic seal on the lid. If you just need the lid to stay on the container, you can remove the plastic seal and use it that way. The dish measures 6″ x 3.5″ x 2.7″, showcasing its tall and deep design for easy storage. It works great with both west and east coast butter and it is designed so that the butter won’t stick to the lid when you pull it off.

Key Features:

  • Lid is made from beech wood
  • Measures 6″ x 3.5″ x 2.7″
  • Butter won’t stick to the lid
Sweese 303.101 Large Butter Dish - Airtight Butter Keeper Holds Up to 2 Sticks of Butter - Porc… Price:$19.99 Buy Now Available from Amazon, BGR may receive a commission

Keep the butter in place

You won’t always need to store butter in your butter dish, so you’re going to want something wide and deep enough to hold multiple foods. With the OXO Good Grips Wide Butter & Cream Cheese Dish, you’ll have your breakfast storage covered. This comfortably holds European-style wide butter, two standard butter sticks or eight ounces of cream cheese, giving you a lot of flexibility. You can cut the spreads right on the dish, as there are non-slip stoppers and feet on either side that keeps it in place while you’re using it. The dish has raised edges, which will keep the butter in place and prevent it from touching the lid. We really loved how the lid is clear, so you can easily identify what you have in there. Also, the lid rests on top of the dish and seals it, allowing you to carry it without it falling off. So any trip you have to make from the fridge to the table are made easy. It’s dishwasher safe, so you can keep it clean by just tossing it in.

Key Features:

  • Raised edges
  • European-style wide butter holds easily
  • Safe to wash in the dishwasher
OXO Good Grips Wide Butter & Cream Cheese Dish List Price:$15.95 Price:$9.99 ($9.99 / Count) You Save:$5.96 (37%) Buy Now Available from Amazon, BGR may receive a commission

Do more with it

You can speed up that softening process by putting your butter in the microwave. But you’ll need a dish that can handle that and the Lock & Lock HPL956 Easy Essentials Specialty Food Storage Container is up to the task. This can be used in the microwave, freezer or the top rack of the dishwasher and it has a unique, stackable design that is easy to store. It is BPA-free and FDA-approved, so it’s safe to use in your kitchen. The real highlight of this dish is the patented, locking lid that is leakproof and watertight. It has a four-hinge locking system and a silicone seal to keep the contents of the container secure. It is made from high quality materials that are long-lasting and durable. The lid can be used as a makeshift cutting board. This truly does provide you with a ton of options.

Key Features:

  • Use the lid as a cutting board
  • FDA-approved
  • BPA-free
LocknLock Easy Essentials Food Storage lids/Airtight containers, BPA Free, Butter-25 oz, Clear List Price:$9.81 Price:$6.99 You Save:$2.82 (29%) Buy Now Available from Amazon, BGR may receive a commission

Don’t dirty an extra knife

Best with a KnifeImage source: Kontactic/Amazon

With the Kontactic White Butter Dish with Lid, you’ll be spreading your butter in no time. The dish is made from white porcelain and the lid is made from bamboo. Inside the lid is a stainless steel knife that stores in there, allowing you to always have one on hand. You can then turn the lid around and cut the butter on the lid, using it as a cutting board. This measures 6.3″ x 3.7″ x 2.7″ and is big enough to hold two sticks of east coast butter and one stick of west coast butter. The airtight silicone ring keeps it sealed when its in the fridge.

Key Features:

  • Bamboo lid
  • Stainless steel knife stores inside the lid
  • Airtight silicone ring
White Butter Dish with Lid 650ml | Butter Dishes with Covers | Covered Butter Dish for Countert… List Price:$16.99 Price:$14.99 You Save:$2.00 (12%) Buy Now Available from Amazon, BGR may receive a commission

Fit in with your kitchen

Best Color VarietyImage source: Butterie/Amazon

You won’t struggle to find a Butterie Flip-Top Butter Dish with Matching Spreader to match your interior decorating. This comes in 10 different colors: aqua, black, cobalt blue, gray, light blue, purple, red, taupe, white, and yellow. This holds eight ounce of butter and comes in a two-piece design to avoid any mess. This includes a hidden knife on the edges and it has a non-slip base. The attached lid does pop off, making cleaning simpler.

Key Features:

  • Offered in 10 colors
  • Holds eight ounces
  • Two-piece design
Butterie Flip-Top Butter Dish with Matching Spreader (Grey) Price:$17.99 Buy Now Available from Amazon, BGR may receive a commission

Chris Hachey handles e-commerce and sponsored content for BGR. He has worked as an editor and writer for over a decade for various publications and distribution services. He focuses on consumer products to help you find the best of what's on the market. When he's not searching for the top deals, he's likely watching his favorite sports teams or walking around his hometown with his fiancée and his dog.

Popular News