Google’s Schmidt: Motorola buy is about ‘more than just patents’

Business

Google Executive Chairman and former CEO Eric Schmidt on Thursday reiterated that the company’s proposed $12.5 billion acquisition of Motorola Mobility is about more than just patents. When Google announced the deal, CEO Larry Page said in a statement, ”Motorola Mobility’s total commitment to Android has created a natural fit for our two companies. Together, we will create amazing user experiences that supercharge the entire Android ecosystem for the benefit of consumers, partners and developers. I look forward to welcoming Motorolans to our family of Googlers.” He also noted, however, that Motorola’s extensive patent portfolio would greatly assist Google and its Android partners in defending Android against patent complaints from the likes of Apple and Microsoft. Read on for more.

Several experts have since weighed in on the acquisition, and many believe Motorola’s portfolio of 25,000 issued and pending patents will do less to protect Android than initially believed. One patent expert went so far as to call the deal “an immense mistake.” On stage at the Salesforce.com Dreamforce conference, Schmidt made certain to communicate that the benefits of the Motorola buy extend beyond patents. “We did it for more than just patents. We actually believe that the Motorola team has some amazing products coming,” Schmidt told Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff on stage at the conference. “We’re excited to have the product line, to use the Motorola brand, the product architecture, the engineers. These guys invested the RAZR. We know them well because they’re Google Apps users.” He continued, “[We enjoy] having at least one area where we can do integrated hardware and software.”

Schmidt continued, noting that the current U.S. patent system has created a hostile environment that is in serious need of an overhaul. His only idea for a proposed solution, however — to crowd-source patent applications and let the general public comment on possible prior art — is not legal under the current system.

Read

74 Comments
  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Evan-Benford/100000812460847 Evan Benford

    Im better than this…no im not nvm. FIRST!

    • Anonymous

      you’re right about that

      • Anonymous

        “We know them well because they’re Google Apps users.”

        thats fucking scary…. i seriously just deleted my google account

      • Anonymous

        wow,, I just got a $829.99 iPad2 for only $103.37 and my mom got a $1499.99 HDTV for only $251.92, they are both coming with USPS tomorrow. I would be an idiot to ever pay full retail prices at places like Walmart or Bestbuy. I sold a 37″ HDTV to my boss for $600 that I only paid $78.24 for.
        I use EgoWîn.com

      • Mr. Dobolina

        Look, we know you and your mom are idiots, this does nothing to change our perceptions.

      • Substring

        This is just a spam to promote the web site. Ignore it.

      • Lavon Moore

        FUCK OFF

    • Haha

      first to be in the welfare line?

      • Gun2hd

        HA HA. Good one WalMart?

      • Anonymous

        Yes because 2/3 of all people on welfare are white.

      • Stoopered

        Im not racist, and I really don’t care and see why ignorant people need to bring up race in a blog. @ scottyrob82 you are correct, according to a 1990 statistic, I was unable to find a more recent one. But you have to remember that the amount of people on it. When comparing the Percentage of each race, blacks are much more likely to be on welfare. Its not because ignorant people think their lazy, because everyone in america is lazy compared to other countries. Many black families were under privilaged from the get go, so its been hard to overcome that. It is getting better, but I still think it will be many years before we see that statistic change.

  • Michael

    This guy looks like a CREEP!

    • Anonymous

      A really wealthy creep.

      • Anonymous

        he’s a pedo.

    • Haha

      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

       
      DIE APPLE DIE

      DIE JOBS DIE

      • http://twitter.com/gyubok Gyubok Baik

        wow. this guy lacks basic human morals..

      • Haha

        I’m just trying to copy apple, i’m trying to get sued… hahaha

      • http://www.droiddoes.com/ Norm

        RIGHT ON!! DROID DOES!!! Schmidt for prez!!

      • Anonymous

        Haha GO TO HELL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 

    • webby

      The guy is a creep, if you know anything about him.  And I say that being an avid user of the Android OS since Day 1.

    • Plazmic Flame

      Is he giving a speech or dancing to La Cucaracha???

  • Wirelessmodz

    Hey everyone is ripping off everyone. Who cares just build the best shit you can and let us decide who makes the best

    • Substring

      Agree. Just look at Mercedes for example, everyone is copying them. Instead of being a cry baby, Mercedes continues to innovate and continue to be the best in the car industry. That’s the way to go and not by suing everybody.

  • Anonymous

    “where we can do integrated hardware and software”
    BOOM 

    • Prof. Peabody

      exactly. everything else he say’s here is filler. 

  • Booboolala2000

    Google TV coming to a cable box near you.

  • http://www.TheGuruReview.net TGR

    In other words they are going to give Motorola preferential treatment when it relates to Android. As such, other Android partners need to be concerned about this statement.

    • Anonymous

      Yes, those other manufacturers should be fleeing to Microsoft WP7 where they will be on an equal footing with Nokia.  Oh wait.  Perhaps they should flee to Apple where they can build iOS devices?  Nope, can’t do that.  Well, maybe they can develop RIM hardware?  Oh darn, can’t do that either.  Oh well. 

      Face it, this has been well played by Google.  The OEM’s are not going anywhere… especially to WP7 where it is impossible to tell one user experience from the competition.

      • Anonymous

        Really,

        Good points on all accounts.  

        However, as long as all of these companies continue to skin Android, they have themselves to blame for the time consuming process to update.

        I would also like to know exactly how carriers, such as Verizon, AT&T and Sprint contribute to the length of updating the phones.  The information found on the web always has conflicting reports.  

      • Anonymous

        IMO it shouldn’t be the carriers that update the phones. The carriers should be providing cellular and data services, period.

      • Anonymous

        Once Motorola starts to release unskinned stock phones that are always on the latest version of Android, other manufacturers will have to do so too in order to compete.

      • http://www.TheGuruReview.net TGR

        …and you can tell now with Android. PLEASE, all the devices look alike.  Oh wait, yeah that’s why those who are with Android are getting sued.

      • http://www.searingarrow.com AlienSix

        ” especially to WP7 where it is impossible to tell one user experience from the competition.”

        Thats the point, that you dont have to keep learning a different user experience every time you switch phones. Thats what is so jarring to the user. Because the software is the same, OEMs have to compete on Hardware differentiation which can be done, if the OEM sees fit

      • Anonymous

        Hardware manufactures can not compete on on hardware differentiation as Microsoft specifies what the hardware must be.  This is desktop PC’s all over again and its a graveyard for the OEM’s because they only way they can compete is price.

        As for Android, I still think most are missing the point.  People buy only one phone at a time.  It doesn’t matter that Motorola devices look different than Samsung devices.  In fact, it is a positive as it gives consumers more choice.  That is the secret of Android.  That is why the OEMs have adopted it.  That is why the platform continues to grow faster than all of the rest despite the fact it is far and away the biggest.

      • http://www.droiddoes.com/ Norm

        Really8888,

        “People only but one phone at a time” ????? Seriously? That is insane. I buy multiple DROID phones every two mOnths and I think the typical consumer does the same with DROID phones.

      • Doug

        No, really8888, you can do quite a bit of customization as a WP7, there are some floors and some restrictions, but that keeps the bottom end decent.

      • Knight777

        License WebOS. Then they would be on equal footing, maybe ! ! !

      • Anonymous

        moto and google have conflict of interest. nokia and microsoft do not, lesser of two evils. you are clueless.

      • Anonymous

        Except to go back to doing their own thing like it was before Google fed them the “free and open” bull.

    • Gun2hd

      In other words they are going to give them selves preferential treatment. If Google own it.

  • Anonymous

    Of course they’re going to make use of Motorola, to think they’re going to anything else is naive.

  • Bullyboyb

    “The current U.S. patent system has created a hostile environment that is in serious need of an overhaul.”

    I am really getting fed up with google moaning like little teenage girls who haven’t been given their sweeties. What a bunch of losers angling for a free ride. If google owned the patents I am sure they will be saying what a beautiful system that protects intellectual property, encourages innovation and rewards investment in new ideas and technologies.
    Start investing in pure Research and developement and stop moaning hoping the saystem will allow you to ride dirty.

    • Joe Butler

      “Encourages Innovation and rewards investment in new ideas”, have you even been paying attention to these ongoing patent lawsuits.  Apple tried to patent and sue to prevent anyone from having a multitouch screen other than the iPhone.  They’ve sued for being able to slide your finger to unlock your screen.  They are currently suing Samsung for their “Innovative groundbreaking” Rectangle design.  The patents being issued are so insanely generic that there is no other way around but to do some of these features a specific way.  The software patent system is fundamentally flawed and in desperate need of revision.  These baseless generic patent lawsuits are threatening to stifle innovation and limit consumer choice.  That isn’t good for anyone.  This just in….Ford Issued exclusive patent for the steering wheel.  Other car companies should simply create a new way to drive right?

      • Anonymous

        You’re so right.  What people miss is the patent laws are being used to stifle innovation.  Hmm, I wonder who that benefits?

      • Bryguy

        Umm Mr. Garrison did that in south park.

      • Anonymous

        That’s funny, that’s EXACTLY what Eric Schmidt said. I am proud to have you as a gRobot!  You, like I, will stay by Google NO MATTER WHAT.  We will believe EVERYTHING they say.  And so we should!

    • Anonymous

      Hah, funny.  You want Google, a company with more engineers than anyone, to “start investing in research and development”.  I’m amazed so many people forget to think before then start pecking away at their computers.

      • Jeff Earls

        He’s just bitter because Google Buzz leaked his location and his ex-husband tracked him down and beat the shit of out him.

        Google hasn’t sued anyone over patent infringement – is that because they don’t have any patents to sue with, or maybe because they’re not full blown assholes?

        Considering all of the bullshit Apple and Microsoft have pulled over the years – let alone lately, I will never understand the Google hate.

      • Anonymous

        They are a publicly traded company.  Therefore, if they aren’t suing because they don’t want to be assholes, then that makes them gigantic assholes to their investors, which is far far worse.  That would make them the biggest assholes in the world.

        Therefore, they are either gigantic assholes to the people who invest in them, or don’t have a leg to stand on to sue for themselves.  You can choose what you want to believe about them.  I happen to believe it’s because they don’t have a leg to stand on in the patent war, not because they are the most gigantic assholes in the universe.

      • Mac

        Can’t sue over patents when you are the company that steals and copies, you stupid fuck.

      • Anonymous

        Actually engineers is ALL they have.  :-) Throw in an accountant here and there.  

      • Anonymous

        I hate to tell you but the thing Google have more than anything are sales people. That is their business, selling advertising.
        Add to that a healthy smattering of political lobbyists, journalists and anybody else who can put their point of view across.
        They are not an engineering company, they are an advertising company who happens to employ software engineering in their business,

    • Anonymous

      Bullyboy,

      Consider changing your name to BaboonBoy.  Your post ranks Top 5 in the Retardation category of the year.

      It’s okay to criticize and insult people and their companies, but ONLY if you’re somewhat informed on the subject.  Your whole diatribe about “investing in pure research” pertaining to Google makes you look the fool.  

      Also, do your research and look into the corporations who are actively instigating this patent mess.

      • Anonymous

        You tell ‘em! Google is innocent and always is, no matter what. Google is our lord savior.

      • Joe Butler

        Goofan you are the biggest hypocryte in the world.  Anyone without the Apple Fleece pulled over their eyes can see that no other company has launched more baseless, generic lawsuits, or performed as many unethical business practices as Apple has in the mobile field as of late.  Just because you worship Apple doesn’t mean you have to ignore the fact that they are making a mockery of the legal system in a sad attempt to stifle the competition that offers so much more than Apple is willing to give its customers.  All Apple does anymore is copy Android and other competitors features in their new model updates anyways.  The revolutionary upcoming iPhone 5.  Featuring an 8 MP Camera, a dual-core processor, BBMerrrrrrrr………. iChat, and a pull-down notification system.  Hmmmmmmm where have I seen all those features before.  Masterful innovators your beloved Apple is. 

      • Anonymous

        @google-9d3befbd66d426336495df79c00a2c79:disqus hey man, it’s ok, your hatred for Apple consumes you and I am ok with that.  It saddens me a bit that people have this hatred for a company they THINK they know.  I hate them because it’s fun to hate them.  It makes me popular with my other nerd friends.  It’s an excellent spectator sport.  :-)

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_TEWRNSIMPYAOI6X32X6P2N7F4M Emma Olson

      I just got a $829.99 iPad2 for only $103.37 and my mom got a $1499.99 HDTV for only $251.92, they are both coming with USPS tomorrow. I would be an idiot to ever pay full retail prices at places like Walmart or Bestbuy. I sold a 37″ HDTV to my boss for $600 that I only paid $78.24 for. I use BidsOut.c om

  • Anonymous

    google’s purpose here is two fold, one is of course that patent portfolio, but more importunely the purchase of motorola was control. one of googles main gripes about carriers are there ui overlays,, they bog down android and are bloatware to say the least. taking control of this using motorola will help android develop. also i think they are taking notes from apple, control the product from design to showroom floor, google assembles hardware, makes android optimized for that hardware, and reaps all the reward,,,

    • Anonymous

      If that is genuinely what they are doing , expect Samsung, HTC et al to jump ship.
      This whole thing is about stopping Motorola rocking the boat by demanding licenses from the other Android “partners”.
      Motorola saw they were going to lose and starting trying to get something off the others. Google bought them to stop that but it will cost them dearly.  $12.5M is a lot of money to try to recoup from a failing company.

  • Anonymous

    In this society (the states) there seems to be hostility toward people, programs, anyone who doesn’t profess to be ‘in it’ for the money. Not to say that sergei brin and larry page don’t want to be rich but they never came across to me as wanting that to be their motivation…

  • Anonymous

    Google has a ecosystem? gtfo. Since when?

    • http://www.droiddoes.com/ Norm

      Well it’s still in BETA like everything they do.

      • Anonymous

        Just like humanity!

  • Anonymous

    lol, Yeah OK, who is he trying to fool?
    total-privacy.int.tc

  • Anonymous

    Time will tell. 

  • Booboolala2000

    Protecting the UI on Android smartphones and the patents are great, but I think this is more about Motorola Cable boxes and Google TV. That is a huge market.

    • Flintchesthair

      I 100% agree. It seems like they are hiding this purchase behind android, while using it propel their net neutrality agenda.

      Btw, this whole net neutrality debate is fascinating.

  • Anonymous

    He only ever gets photographed from straight ahead so you can’t see his nose growing

  • Mac

    He is one ugly fuck, just like Android.  What a perfect match.

    • Solutionman

      Yea, but he’d have the finest Asian booty in San Fran,,,n not just cause he has $$$. Amazing how Asian chicks worship nerdy ass White men that nobody else would want…

      • Solutionman

        White worship n low self esteem at it’s finest.

  • Solutionman

    Goddamn that man looks like a friggin robot. Guess the term ‘droid’ is appropriate huh? Looks like a friggin barrel of laughs too. Sheesh.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_M7H3WRFYBGORT4FRK3HIZQH33M Clare Tyson

    I just got a $829.99 iPad2 for only $103.37 and my mom got a $1499.99 HDTV for only $251.92, they are both coming with USPS tomorrow. I would be an idiot to ever pay full retail prices at places like Walmart or Bestbuy. I sold a 37″ HDTV to my boss for $600 that I only paid $78.24 for. I use PennyOrder.comONLY

  • Anonymous

    His tie is on backwards

blog comments powered by Disqus