U.S. government sues to block AT&T, T-Mobile merger [updated]

Breaking

The United States government has filed a lawsuit in an attempt to block AT&T’s proposed $39 billion acquisition of T-Mobile USA, saying that such a deal would “substantially lessen competition” in the U.S. wireless market. Bloomberg reports that the complaint was filed by the U.S. Justice Department on Wednesday, and the government is asking for a declaration that the proposed merger would violate U.S. antitrust laws. The complaint seeks to have the deal blocked as a result. “AT&T’s elimination of T-Mobile as an independent, low- priced rival would remove a significant competitive force from the market,” the U.S. said in its filing. AT&T has argued that it needs T-Mobile’s spectrum in order to improve service quality and cover the majority of the U.S. population with 4G LTE service.

UPDATE: AT&T has issued a statement in response to the DOJ lawsuit. The FCC has issued a statement as well, as has Sprint.

Read

125 Comments
  • Gara56

    The US gov’t should be spending its resources help Americans get jobs, fix crumbling infrastructure and get its budget in order. Just shows that they consistently have their priorities mixed up.

    • Bullet Tooth Tony

      I believe you’re confusing Congress - who creates legislation that would address those things - with actual entities of government actually doing their jobs that they get paid for, whether you agree with the decision or not.

      If you have a beef with Congress not doing their jobs… write a note to John Boner.

  • Jbrown362

    These is the best news so far in this whole att merger.

  • http://twitter.com/computer_tweets KW

    the best mobile company (AT&T) taking over the worst mobile company (T-Mobile)­. nothing wrong with that!

    • http://www.facebook.com/japultra Jason Nguyen

      AT&T is the best? What are you smoking?

  • Anonymous

    As they should….this was going to do nothing positive for consumers.

  • Steveh_rocks

    It will still go thru.

  • Anonymous

    So is this over? Done deal, no go ?

    Or is it possible that At&t could potentially win the suit against them?

    Either way im sure tmo will be happy with 3 billion and some spectrum right

    • http://twitter.com/dustbeta Dustin Schultz

      Why would they be happy?  Deutsche Telekom doesn’t want it any more, losing money.  They want to sell.  And no, it’s not over yet.

    • Bullet Tooth Tony

      3 billion dollars is like trying to put a bandaid over a gaping arterial wound.  DT put T-Mobile USA up for sale for a reason….

      • serpentor

        Not all companies are put up for sale because they’re losing money.

      • Bullet Tooth Tony

        Ok… well, we can make that argument when it actually applies to the companies we are talking about.  DT put T-Mobile USA up for sale for a reason.  And that reason was losing money, losing a *record* number of subscribers each quarter and proceding to break its own record the next quarter.  And to make their losses even harder to swallow, their operating revenues are plummeting.

      • serpentor

        @7c0cc0fac3083d0d187aad15ce368ae3:disqus That’s what I was getting at.

        And the facts don’t back you up: they gained 137k, then lost 23k, then 99k, then 50k customers the past 3 quarters.

        They banked over 200 million last quarter, so no they’re not losing money.

      • Bullet Tooth Tony

        You really need to learn how to read earnings if you want to discuss this… They had 200 million dollars of ***revenue***… revenue and profit aren’t the same thing.  Revenue does not take into account expenses and cash outflow… ya know, like salaries, maintenance of its network, expansion of its network… and their electric bills, water bills, lease payments… so  with 42,000 employees, 200 million dollars is nothing.  That’s less than 5000 dollars per employee for the quarter… so the question must be asked… do you assume that T-Mobile pays each one of its employees barely more than 19,000 dollars per year and offers no health insurance or 401k benefits?  And obviously, they lease their office buildings for free… right?

      • Bullet Tooth Tony

        And at myself… I’m sure I’m even a mile off on revenues without looking them up.  But T-Mobile USA isn’t in a healthy position currently.  Whatever the numbers are — losing their contracts is not good for their future, revenues declining are bad, and losing handset money…. all negative signs.  This isn’t Sprint shedding old customers on retired plans that boosts its overall financials  These are healthy contracts they are losing.

      • serpentor

        From their latest quarterly earnings:

        Service revenues in the  second quarter of 2011  of $4.6 billion

        $4 Billion in REVENUE from contracts.

        $5 Billion in total REVENUE

        NET INCOME = $212 million

        There’s a difference between DECLINING revenues, and profits VS LOSING MONEY.

      • serpentor, CPA

        I didn’t read the tmo’s quarterly earnings word for word, but did you even take a look at it?

      • serpentor

        Think about it – $200 million in revenue from 34 million customers would mean an average bill of about $2 Dollars per month.

      • Bullet Tooth Tony

        “They banked over 200 million last quarter, so no they’re not losing money.”

        Your numbers, not mine. Precisely why I said they were probably wrong numbers in a separate post afterwards. No, I didn’t look them up. I’m typing on my Thunderbolt. Not exactly conducive to research. The specifics, however, are irrelevant. They have an unsustainable business. Their continued losses make it so. They can’t compete with prices on prepaid services, and they can’t hold on to postpaid. They aren’t long for this world, so to speak.

  • http://twitter.com/Kevniv Kevin N

    Sounds like this is over. Thank god! I hate AT&T

  • http://twitter.com/drbyers Donnie Byers

    I love it when everybody gets their panties in a bunch over seemingly nothing. 

    What would the ATT subscribers on here gain by their carrier acquiring Tmobile? 

    Bragging rights? Lower prices (good luck with that)? The hawt chick from the commercials?

    You’ll all live through this, as will Tmobile, especially when it gets its own version of the iPhone in October. 

    Just remember: Competition good. Monopolies bad. 

  • Matt Kats

    “the complaint was filed with the U.S. Justice Department on Wednesday” 
    The complain was filed BY the US Justice Department WITH the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. 

  • ShaunZee

    How refreshing. Thank you Congress, I was starting to lose complete faith in You. Maybe there is hope for America after all.

    • http://MobileGenius.wordpress.com JM

      This is the DOJ, not Congress, as they still cant decide on anything without two months of name-calling.

  • Anonymous

    VZW and AT&T have had the same prices ever since they have been “competing” with each other, maybe the DOJ needs a closer look at it’s wireless bill…

  • Anonymous

    Probably the Government realizes the antirust problem caused by the acquisition.

  • http://twitter.com/_fredLjones Fredrick Jones

    This says something

  • http://twitter.com/elleryfamilia Ellery Familia

    +1 Humans

    This is a win for consumers. We can’t let AT&T swallow T-Mobile. T-Mobile and Sprint are responsible for forcing the larger carriers to lower their prices.

  • Rlbre

    I know people are happy about this for whatever reason but T mobile has said in the past that they are nit interested in spending any more money on their US network.
    They will go bankrupt and close shop if Att can’t buy them.

  • Man_of_god_99

    If T-Mo goes under, how does that help consumers? They have been up for sale for 5 years. If they suspend operation in the US then what?

  • Delacy Sanford

    ever notice how people throw out words like antitrust and monopoly but by definition they dont apply in this case.

    hint: “definition”

  • Anonymous

    This is like the Navy’s version of a cannon shot over the bow.  Very bad news for ATT.

  • Anonymous

    good news for consumers! and better if T-Mobile can give their customers better coverage.

  • John Smith

    Why don’t they stop google and other companies from buying up all the competition???

  • Delacy Sanford

    hmmmm basic individual plans….4 carriers…..starting price $39.99….one has 50 minutes more, one has rollover, one has the nations most reliable network, and the other sprint. yeah i see how this can hurt competition.

1 2
blog comments powered by Disqus