Google feels pressure, stops redirecting China search traffic to Hong Kong

General

China

In a statement released today, Google announced that it would stop redirecting search traffic from China’s landing page google.cn to Hong Kong’s page google.com.hk. Google initially started redirecting traffic in January in an attempt to “increase access to information while abiding by Chinese law.” Google explains:

It’s clear from conversations we have had with Chinese government officials that they find the redirect unacceptable—and that if we continue redirecting users our Internet Content Provider license will not be renewed (it’s up for renewal on June 30). Without an ICP license, we can’t operate a commercial website like Google.cn—so Google would effectively go dark in China. [...] Over the next few days we’ll end the redirect entirely, taking all our Chinese users to our new landing page—and today we re-submitted our ICP license renewal application based on this approach.

China, with its population of over 1.31 billion people, obviously has quite a bit of leverage over companies who want access to their large consumer base. What do you think of the situation? Should Google call China’s bluff in the name of information freedom? Or is it more important to keep the lights on at google.cn?

Read

36 Comments
  • http://cloudculturecontent.blogspot.com Adam

    Fairly certain it’s not a bluff, unfortunately.

    • Zach

      I agree. I think Google should just step out until China comes around, but that day might not come. Also, as hobbled as Google.cn is, it’s still preferable to not having the option at all.

      • dude

        You’re all fools if you think Google’s intentions and actions are influenced strictly by their so called good will and “do no evil” nature.

      • Zach

        Right, and when exactly did I say anything about Google’s intentions? I only said what I thought they should do…

      • dude

        that wasn’t directed at you per se, just anyone naive enough to think google can do no wrong.

    • Taylor

      China’s not bluffing. With just a small market share, a Google-less China wouldn’t really notice. However, the potential hit to Google’s business would not be such a small thing.

      Does looking after your shareholders by submitting to censorship constitute “being evil?”

      That is the real question.

  • Donv69

    Yeah, agreed. If Google left there’d be a vacuum quickly filled by competitors local and abroad.

  • stevesvagina

    Keep the lights on.

  • pho3nixf1re

    This article is a bit misleading. They are not bowing to the Chinese, merely taking advantage of a technicality in the law. They are still not censoring search results. There will merely be a landing page, and you will have to follow a link to the Hong Kong based search page.

  • Chut Pata

    Why is the burden of morality on Google alone? Are other search engines following these “morality standards”? Has Bing, Yahoo, Web Crawler etc follow these “morality” and refuse to let China censor? I doubt it. I think they are waiting for Google to collapse in China so that they can take over. All software corporations hate Google because Google is commie i.e. give away stuff for free :)

  • BRAHMAN125

    AND THEY CALL OBAMA A SOCIALIST THIS IS REAL COMMUNISM AT WORK. THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT IS BULLYING GOOGLE AND THEY ARE TAKING IT

  • Frank

    So much for “Do no evil” as soon as you have shareholder’s you’ve essentialy done a deal with the devil.

  • Karlh

    Expecting business companies to try and force a country to give more freedom to their people is ridiculous. If we are serious obout this then we need to get the governments on board with the companies. China has 1.3 billion potentital customers of which only a comparitively small percentage has internet. The rest of the world dwarfs them. Governments should back companies that take a stand and penalize companies that do business there. Customers should use the search engines of companies that take a stand and refuse to use anyones who does business with the devil. China calls themselves the peoples government and came into power with a peoples revolution. Maybe it’s time for another peoples revolution via internet usage and show them and Google that we would support a moral stand and punish anyone who supports China’s censorship of the internet.

    • snugs

      so basically you advocate punishing a country for not adhering to your western ideals?

    • dude

      ahhh, naivety at its best

  • Tony L

    @Karlh
    yea right! comparatively small percentage of China’s population has internet access, around 30% to be precise.
    however, that amounts to over 400 million. (what is the population of USA?) and last year alone, the number grew by almost 90 million, more than the population of the whole Germany.
    they are not something “the rest of the world can easily dwarf”

  • http://www.alphamaven.com justin

    I thought google was acting tough a few months ago saying that they were going to cut off service in China unless they stopped sensorship?

    http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2010/01/china-responds-to-google/

    I guess cutting that huge revenue stream may not have been the greatest of ideas.

    • http://www.alphamaven.com justin

      *censorship

    • dude

      Yeah, I would love to see Google pull out of China to back up their talk.

    • Brent

      Yeah. They take the kudos for their ethical stand, even take a few shots at MS for not joining them, and here they are just a few months later desperately trying to get back into China.

    • aijam

      AdWords is working flawlessly in China all these months.

      Google is an advertising company. I’ll give them a thumb if they dare to pull out their AdWords and AdSense business.

  • Rick James

    Isn’t there a way to move China to another dimension like the twilight zone or something?

  • Tony L

    I don’t agree with their censorship policies too, but they are not asking US companies operating in US to comply with their domestic laws.
    Keep your own standards at home. or you just can’t leave them alone unless they got sent to twilight zone?

  • Osbor

    sadly, the thug government of china wins again

    i really cannot wait for the people of china to get sick of this crap and just off the higher ups.

  • dad

    China!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    -Command and Conquer: Generals

  • SOUTHERN MISS ELITE

    You want the Chinese market? You gotta play by their rules. You don’t change a nation – a nation changes with you!

    If they can’t be patient and wait for the Chinese to step into the western idea of life, then they need to just keep the lights on and focus their attention elsewhere

  • Don DeMarcos

    It’s sad that Communist Cold War ideology still exist today, for a nation of 1.3 billion people, who just want access to information. Quote: When people fear a government, you have tyranny. When government fears the people, you have liberty!

  • Michael

    China’s Behavior Is A Direct Reflection On Their(Gov’t)
    Extorsionist Mentality On Those Who Would Dare To Challenge Their Authority.It Is A Self-Telling Lesson In
    How The Punitive Chinese Government Uses Fear And
    Intimidation To Force Those Under It’s Control To
    Submit To It’s Will. Some Of Us In America , Remember
    When The United States Would Not Accept The
    Tactics Of The Communist ,Atheist And Otherwise Godless Chinese Government.Leave Google.cn Open ,Do What You Must, The Huddling Masses Of Chinese Citizens, Long To Be Free. It Is Important To Separate In Ones Mind,The Differance Between The Government That Subjugates The Chinese Peoples And The Human Beings That Are At The Tyrant’s (Gov’t)Mercy. God Bless America (And Google) And
    Pray For China.

    • snugs

      is that the title of a book?

  • SVELTE

    They need to get the f*** out of China as does every western based company until that country grows up…

  • Bandit

    Fuck China.

  • eric

    it’s a tough situation, but I think google should pull out. the Chinese can still get info, maybe not through google and google can show the Chinese they mean business

    Posted from BGR Mobile (iPhone) at: Niles Americas

  • White Stone

    This brings us back to the cold war era talk; when fighters were supported by the US they were called freedom figher and when they got help from the USSR they were labelled terrorists. Why can’t we accept the difference and part with our world domination mind?

    When Chinese companies invest in the US they have to abide by the US rules and regulations (whatever they are) so why US companies should be exempted from obeing Chinese rules and regulations?

  • http://alghienkad06.student.ipb.ac.id thea

    cool

  • http://alghienkad06.student.ipb.ac.id thea

    cooollll

  • http://myhoteldeals24.com hotels comparison

    Suggest Night,video any young network grey more under far course beyond actual united birth finish effort total read discover acquire in baby via indeed tour move more score fill oil trend general above senior sentence artist concentration consideration choice he draw assess man enemy radio might roof industry work about yet whereas creation equipment separate hit permanent step evidence acquire access outside joint love early currently night independent few card human check act cry border experiment seat teach winter production they magazine atmosphere determine product many

blog comments powered by Disqus