Canada's proposed Copyright Act amendments will make it illegal to break DRM

Legal

canada

After weeks of leaks and speculation, Canada’s reigning Conservative government outlined its plans to amend the ageing Copyright Act. According to the outline, anyone convicted of bypassing the DRM of a given media format — even if legally purchased — will be subject to a fine of up to $5,000. But if the circumvention of DRM is done for profit, then the fine is raised to $1 million. Convicted downloaders of copyrighted materials will face significantly weaker penalties with a fine of $5,000, down from the present day maximum of $20,000. Canadians will also be allowed to use copyrighted materials to create mashup videos for sites such as YouTube, and the law books will finally acknowledge that commonplace activities such as recording TV, radio and internet broadcasts are okay. The same applies for backing media for personal use or archival purposes, but so long as DRM is not tampered with. Cellphone unlocking was not mentioned, although Heritage Minister Tony Clement said that it is currently legal to unlock phones so long as that phone is not currently under contract from a carrier. In an editorial co-autored with Heritage Minister James Moore published in The National Post on Wednesday, Clement argued that “Canada’s Copyright Act is more than 80 years old and has not been significantly modified for many years” and needs a serious overhaul in order to protect the interests of Canadians and the rights of content creators. The legislation is expected to be tabled in the House of Commons on Thursday.

Read

 

24 Comments
  • Bla1ze

    Haaa! Still better than what some other countries face.

  • YAZombie

    “in order to protect the interests of Canadians”: my ass!

  • fred

    ” to protect the interest of large corporations “

  • Counting Apples

    d
    o
    w
    n
    L
    o
    a
    d
    MORE

  • seabass

    Wow way to go canada good looking out for the people!!! They should just government ran by a large corporation.

  • Apocalypse

    I pay for all my music and movies. Why don’t you?

    • George

      Downloading tends to be cheaper.

  • LazyStarGazer

    Looking out for the interests of Canadians? Uhh, how ya figure?

    Looking out for content creators? Definitely.

    • Dale McNamee

      Hey Lazy,

      Why don’t YOU create content in the Public Domain (no copyright ),publish it, put it up on the web FOR FREE and absorb the costs of doing so ?

      How long do you think that you’ll be around ?

      • Shelton

        Is there a subscription fee for this blog???? Hey BGR how long you guys been up for now 3+ years. and last I checked distributing a file mp3 over the internet is alot cheaper then hosting a blog and having a domain name.

  • jesseps

    I pay for my music. I download tv shows that are not allowed in Canada because of the CRTC (so what does this law do for me/to me?) and as for movies I pay them at the cinema.

  • 123abc

    According to the outline, anyone convicted of bypassing the DRM of a given media format — even if legally purchased — will be subject to a fine of up to $5,000

    So basically, if I purchase an album from itunes and create a CD of it so I can listen to it in my car, I will be subject to a $5000 fine?

    As far as I can tell, when I burn the CD, the DRM cannot be transferred to the CD. Therefore, the DRM is bypassed because one can take the CD and rip it back to the computer and viola… DRM free. I didn’t make this up, this trick is all over the Internet.

    How about a person who purchased a thousand songs on iTunes over the years and then decides to use a Zune instead? Last time I checked, Canadians have a right to switch players. How do I transfer these songs over to the Zune format whilst keeping the DRM intact?

    Again, it looks like the people who came up with this bill are not familiar with the technology in question.

    BTW, how many Heritage Ministers have we got?
    “although Heritage Minister Tony Clement said”
    and
    “In an editorial co-autored with Heritage Minister James Moore”

  • Mr. Sky

    I’ll just never purchase anything from itunes

  • Kall

    I’m not sure I understand this now… They say we can record TV and make archival backups, however both TV and Movies all have a form of DRM, which in their words is not allowed to be backed up or recorded?

    So what was the point of allowing the backups or recording TV?

    I may be missing something though, (I really hope so.) Please correct me if I’m wrong.

  • http://wireheadednoodlebrain.blogspot.com/ Taming

    Read Michael Geist for a different take on this. He has been an indefatigable advocate for digital rights and has been accurately analyzing what is happening here for a long, long time.

    He is a law professor at the University of Ottawa where he holds the Canada Research Chair in Internet and E-commerce Law and has received numerous awards for his work including the Electronic Frontier Foundation’s Pioneer Award in 2008, Canarie’s IWAY Public Leadership Award for his contribution to the development of the Internet in Canada.

    http://www.michaelgeist.ca/content/view/5080/125/

  • Chris

    Music, movies and television
    sucks so bad now it’s any wonder these laws have to be changed to stop people from stealing. Nobody wants to pay for the garbage we listen to or watch anymore. Lady Gaga? What the fuck is that? The Fray? You call that music? You really think The Hangover was a good movie? The Bachelor? Please! Produce something good and I’ll gladly pay for it.

  • monchiron

    “protect the interest of Canadian” my ass too

  • SVELTE

    Canada is a silly place…

    • maxpayne79

      lol…thats funny. but at least we don’t have terrorists here…yet.

      • Shelton

        Umm take a history Lesson. FLQ, the ecoterrorists in bc.

  • maxpayne79

    “Cash fuels everything around me, cream get the money, dollar dollar bill ya’ll” – M.a.t.h.o.d.

  • shane fugere

    I admitt were silly, laid back and love to laugh at ourselves. So take that u bunch of hosiers eh. LMAO… Have a good day

  • Confused

    Wow this is sure confusing, people can now record tv or movies or music as long as they don’t go around the protection or locks to get it? They sure didn’t word that right. It sure opens a can of worms, because it’s only the original offender that has broken the law, once the original hack has made a copy of something it’s an unprotected file so all people after that are now innocent of going around protection? as it passes to a trillion others? This Monster is out of control to say the least. So under the new law a person can record right off their movie channel to a DVD recorder, transfer to their Ipod or PC or do whatever they want with it as long as they didn’t go around a lock? and this is going to stop people from what exactly? Sounds like they are being given the green light to do whatever they want to me?

  • Garth

    This amendment definitely has some flaws. For example, one who purchases downloadable content should be able to break the DRM so it can be converted into any format the users device can play.

blog comments powered by Disqus